Their "Magical Season" was only magical in their eyes. They were a one trick pony that rode him till that pony could no longer run.
They can't claim "Recognition" when fans of the team they just beat don't remember them. I was in Little Rock the weekend of our Arkasas game and was just wearing a Ragin Cajun shirt and flag on my care. No other school name. All I heard from their fans were "aww we play y'all again" before the game and then after it was "so good to get one back". After the first 5 I stopped correcting them.
If NLULM wants recognition, they should just go with "University of Monroe". There is no other NCAA school with that name. It also sounds Presidential.