Defensive Holding Call ?

[cjr3888]

Thats the mark of a young QB. Nobody knows that rules until they see it or it happens to them.


igeaux.mobi

[Just1More]

_ Thats the mark of a young QB. Nobody knows that rules until they see it or it happens to them.


igeaux.mobi _

Maybe in highschool. All college QBs should know that rule. It isn't like I fault him for the kneejerk attempt under fire... but afterwards... he shouldn't have been looking at the ref with a "what did I do wrong?" He should have known. Today, Riley Dodge is asking if that footage can be stricken from replay.

[NOCajun]

I was sitting on the other side of the field and did not see the play, but talked to someone afterwards who said he saw the holding basically happen right in front of him. I have no reason to doubt him.

[Pirogue]

_ Maybe in highschool. All college QBs should know that rule. It isn't like I fault him for the kneejerk attempt under fire... but afterwards... he shouldn't have been looking at the ref with a "what did I do wrong?" He should have known. Today, Riley Dodge is asking if that footage can be stricken from replay. _

When Jake did it as a freshman... he almost had to be ejected he was arguing so much with the officials...

After the game he explained that the play was legal at Tuerlings...

apparently they ran that

[Pirogue]

_ I was sitting on the other side of the field and did not see the play, but talked to someone afterwards who said he saw the holding basically happen right in front of him. I have no reason to doubt him. _

It happened inches from me... it was basically an uncathchable Pass intereference call - holding... you can't touch the receiver like that... but I often see it not called.

That was a break.

[NOCajun]

_ It happened inches from me... it was basically an uncathchable Pass intereference call - holding... you can't touch the receiver like that... but I often see it not called.

That was a break. _

You may call it a break, but the right call should never have to be considered that way. I just thank GOD the ref saw it at all!!!

[Cajunsmike]

_ It happened inches from me... it was basically an uncathchable Pass intereference call - holding... you can't touch the receiver like that... but I often see it not called.

That was a break. _

I have no doubt the ref called defensive holding rather than pass interference. In fact, he stated the infraction was before the pass was thrown when announcing the penalty.

[Pirogue]

_ I have no doubt the ref called defensive holding rather than pass interference. In fact, he stated the infraction was before the pass was thrown when announcing the penalty. _

It was "holding" when he called it, but I think...

He said that to quiet the two North Texas defensive backs screaming in his face that the ball was "uncatchable" and it was...

Had they not influenced him that way he may have called Pass interference, had he done that... then after a conference the flag would have likely been "waived off"

Refs, or at least I've never seen it, waive off a penalty after they throw a flag before making a call because of something a player says...

I feel like he threw the flag for P.I. realized it was uncatchable from the North Texas players, and changed the call before he made the signal to holding [which happened... the receiver was held]

That was a break.... the planets were lining up.

[DaddyCajun]

_ I was standing on the sideline in front of the play and he had his jersey from the back before the ball was thrown. I was surprised the official saw it, they usually don't call it. The infraction happened before the pass. _

Saw the same thing. My Uncle who is a ref(official) was sitting with us and he called it from the stands, just prior to the ref throwing the flag. It is very nice watching a game with him.

[Parrott]

I was on the sideline. There was a hold, although I think the official originally was going to call pass interference.


igeaux.mobi