Mid Majors vs. Transfer Portal

[jcstewart]

Wet blanket response to that approach is we bear the risk of taking shots on HS kids, develop them into starters for them to get poached for $$$.

Gotta make transfers sit a year again. That would helps slow this landslide of the portal down.

[CajunEXPRESS]

One year sit out. Very few exceptions and all have to be objective and not subjective. But that horse is out the barn.

[CajunVic]

Sitting out a year will never happen again.

[RCAJUN90]

Sitting out a year will never happen again.

Do they still make NCAA players attend classes? It seems like a annoying formality. No school pride etc…. If this morphs into a farm system for the P5, I’m done.

[CajunEXPRESS]

Do they still make NCAA players attend classes? It seems like a annoying formality. No school pride etc…. If this morphs into a farm system for the P5, I’m done.

Good bye

[babysitter]

Do they still make NCAA players attend classes? It seems like a annoying formality. No school pride etc…. If this morphs into a farm system for the P5, I’m done.

It will.

[R1Letterman]

How about some kind of quotient or factor added to a team’s score based on average number of stars each recruit is. for example if a team of all 3stars ties a team of all 4stars the 3 would win, because x #of points gets added to their score. could also lead to strategy in recruiting because you wouldnt “extra” 4s and 5s that dont contribute hoggin up your bench and ruining your quotient factor.

[CajunEXPRESS]

How about some kind of quotient or factor added to a team’s score based on average number of stars each recruit is. for example if a team of all 3stars ties a team of all 4stars the 3 would win, because x #of points gets added to their score. could also lead to strategy in recruiting because you wouldnt “extra” 4s and 5s that dont contribute hoggin up your bench and ruining your quotient factor.

You a funny poster.

Of course they’re never going to give back any advantages they currently have. Hell, they’re looking for more advantages.

[R1Letterman]

You a funny poster.

Of course they’re never going to give back any advantages they currently have. Hell, they’re looking for more advantages.

true. but if it werent up to them, if there was some objective body in charge of the rules, in theory, maybe others could expound on the idea?
i had a similar idea in basketball a long time ago, that with rounding obviously, why not make the player’s gpa the amount they get for each bucket in basketball. A 4.0 student’s goals are worth more than the 2.0 minimum eligible player, etc etc. how far would teams be willing to sacrifice overall talent for smarter players, where do you find the perfect mix, seems like it would add another level of strategy to the sport.

[CajunEXPRESS]

true. but if it werent up to them, if there was some objective body in charge of the rules, in theory, maybe others could expound on the idea?
i had a similar idea in basketball a long time ago, that with rounding obviously, why not make the player’s gpa the amount they get for each bucket in basketball. A 4.0 student’s goals are worth more than the 2.0 minimum eligible player, etc etc. how far would teams be willing to sacrifice overall talent for smarter players, where do you find the perfect mix, seems like it would add another level of strategy to the sport.

Besides privacy issues and whoever is going to be the independent agency that the autonomous 5 will accept. You know they pretty much told the NCAA what side of the world the Sun rises on. It’s the East as long as they agree to that. But one day they’re going to explain to the NCAA there’s no true East, only a continuing changing of location.