Travel or "select" baseball is all well and good for kids that are in high school, as long as there are responsible coaches in charge. But it's gotten to the point where its basically mandatory for any player that has aspirations to play any further than low level high school ball.
But it absolutely is killing the sport in the youth age groups. I have friends that are spending their entire weekends traveling all over the state, and paying thousands of dollars for their SIX year old sons to play baseball! That's ridiculous.
And now, if you aren't on one of these teams, or cant afford it, or are just starting to play the game, and haven't developed into a good enough player for it...you either don't play, or are stuck playing in leagues that are on the brink of dissolution. And being coached by dads who don't know the first thing about baseball.
Kids are giving up the game at 7, 8, 9 years old because they aren't good enough for the "select" team. I know from personal experience that a lot of these kids that are so good at that age end up being nothing as high school players. I also know kids who didn't even pick up a baseball until they were 11 or 12 that ended up playing professionally.
Another issue I have with it in the younger age groups (and actually this pertains to the older ones as well)...I coach multiple sports, and have sons that are in middle school. It's appalling to me how many of these kids, and 99% of the ones I'm referring to are the "select" baseball players, are already giving up all of the other sports to "concentrate" on baseball because they have it in their heads that they are great because their parents were willing to pay for them to be on a "select" baseball team. I think that is THE WORST thing that middle school kids can do. They need to be playing as many different sports as they can at that age, and if they are excelling at the high school level after they're sophomores in a single sport, then ok, spend your time with it. But doing that in 7th or 8th grade is doing themselves a huge disservice...in my opinion.