In order for UL to take the program to the next level, everyone including the fans will have to change how you make assessments of players. Your emotions have no place in your decision making as to who should be playing/starting regardless if you support Gautier, Mason or Maguire. You must deal with the actual facts. There is no need to interpret anything. Just look at the stats. The eyeball test should not apply here. Emotions must be kept out of this.
Now some facts: Maguire is 1-2 as a starter (so much for "all he does is wins"). He was independently evaluated by 2 different coaching staffs and not only was he not made the QB starter, his position was changed completely. He is a good player and a good kid but he is not starting QB material based on your last and present coach. Mason coming into the season was the starter in my mind because in my experience having played on that level it is very hard to "dethhrone" the returning starting QB with only practice to use as the evaluation tool. Any player can tell you practice is a lot slower than the actual game. Anyway, what are the Mason stats. He is 11-12 over the last 3 seasons as starter. His passer efficiency rating has gone from 118 (2009) to 116 (2010) to 67 presently with the 2 games he started against very weak competition (Kent State - last in the Mid-American conference and Nicholls State - a middle to lower tier FBS school. Finally Gautier: College sports is like what Janet Jackson said, "What have you done for me lately"". This season Gautier has a passer efficiency rating of 116 so far and has the only passing TD so far this season. He is 3rd on the team in rushing. This was done with only playing about 4 1/2 quarters of football this season (taken off of the UL website where stats are located) with 3 of those quarters coming against the then 9th ranked team in America.
Sorry to be so long but I want to see UL get it to the next level. If you evaluate your program like it is done at winning programs, you would conclude that the QB question has been answered. Gautier should be made the starter and everyone should get behind him. Remember, Mason started for two seasons not Gautier so he will definitely hit a rough patch. It happens to all of us. Get behind him an "Geaux Cajuns",