Yes, I am aware that I am a nerd because I even thought to do this, but here goes...
Eric Crouch 2001 Heisman winner vs. Jerry Babb 2004 projected totals:
Passing Percentage
Crouch- 105/189, 55.6%
Babb Projected- 201/352, 57.1%
Advatage: Babb
Passing Yardage
Crouch- 1510 yd.
Babb Projected- 2239 yd.
Advantage: Babb
Passing Touchdowns
Crouch- 7
Babb Projected- 14
Advantage: Babb
Interceptions:
Crouch- 10
Babb Projected- 14
Advantage: Crouch
Rushing Yardage:
Crouch- 1115 yd.
Babb Projected- 602 yd.
Advantage: Crouch
Rushing Yards/Carry:
Crouch- 5.5
Babb Projected- 6.8
Advantage: Babb
Rushing Touchdowns:
Crouch- 18
Babb Projected- 8
Advantage- Crouch
4-3, Babb wins. Statistics don't lie, people.