I believe it is entirely appropriate to review the contributions of Rickey Bustle and include numerous complimentary remarks. He is a very good person and a good football coach. The circumstances perhaps as much or more than his own abilities may be dictating the necessity of the end of his career at UL. Regardless of which side of that argument you land, it is nonetheless highly necessary that we act with our heads in this case moreso than our hearts. Let the lovers love the next guy too.
Even if someone could argue that Bustle is an outstanding head football coach... when you labor for 9 seasons with an FBS ranking (just one measuring stick of success) of unspectacular proportions, in the world of college football, you must seek new means to find greater success. Has the university done everything it needs to do? Have the fans done their part? Not yet. But that is another requirement of the new mission.
I am a strong advocate of using the mission formula that I know works. You must take one of the most visible contributing factors, the coach, and push a tremendous responsibility... including a hefty pricetag... on their head. I consider him being of fine character and his student-athletes going to class and behaving properly a non-negotiable requirement of the entire school. If it even has to be discussed more than once, there are issues at the school that transcend the coach. The maintenance supervisor had better focus on maintenance and the football coach better be focused on winning football games.
I consider the discussion of the "character of a coach" equivalent to a any other position at UL. Have we done a great background and morality check on every professor at UL? Is it acceptable that one that teaches Philosophy, English or Music is a great teacher, but is an oddball character-wise?
I look at a professor of Computer Science and say "can he teach me what I'm here to learn?". He can be a geek who wears a dress on the weekends for all I care. And as far as the football coach goes... I very much hope his main vocation is coaching football. If he's a sweetheart guy in the process... so be it. Personally, I will keep an eye on his coaching and that is where he will get 98% of the weight of his grade from me.