Noted and respect your opinion as I've seen here you are a stats guy.
Just seems to a common folk to be a bit harsh to say "only Marceaux had good numbers" when it seems as though it's splitting hairs at 11 hits in 38 AB's for Manning vs. 13 hits in 42 AB's for Kennedy. Especially if you do a deep dive into those numbers for a relevant comparison.
Also, my stance here isn't a Madyson vs. Kennedy comparison as I know both personally and think the world of each of them. I am excited that BOTH have decided to be Ragin Cajuns because I think its a great FIT for both, regardless of numbers.
I was just genuinely curious as to what numbers you were looking at to come to that conclusion.
Also, it shouldn't really matter if it was over 1 season or 7 if the "opportunities" were the same (i.e. plate appearances/AB's) no?