NFL HOF skips Brian Mitchell again.

[R1Letterman]

Why do we need to choose?

[Cajunrunner]

Personally, the UL player I want to see in the HOF is Charles "Peanut Punch" Tillman.

I think he gets in within the next few years.

[Cajunrunner]

If Devon Hester is in HOF than in my opinion Brian Mitchell should definitely be in HOF. BM was much more consistent throughout his career than Hester who was more of a flashy player and below average wide receiver.

Devin Hester was a 3 time All-Pro and on two all-decade teams.

Mitchell was a 1 time All Pro.

I know we like to look at things with Vermilion & White glasses, but Hester was always going to be in as a return specialist before Mitchell due to him separating himself from the rest of his peers as a return man during his best seasons. Three times led the NFL in punt return TDs.

[KajunKrazy]

Its just plain criminal that he isn't in the HOF yet. Lead the league in all purpose yards in the history of the NFL the day he retired.

[Turbine]

Devin Hester was a 3 time All-Pro and on two all-decade teams.

Mitchell was a 1 time All Pro.

I know we like to look at things with Vermilion & White glasses, but Hester was always going to be in as a return specialist before Mitchell due to him separating himself from the rest of his peers as a return man during his best seasons. Three times led the NFL in punt return TDs.

Compared to Brian Mitchell he burned out like a bottle rocket.

He never led the entire all-purpose history of the NFL like Brian Mitchell did.

No Hall of Famer kept playing longer than normal (due to Hester) to recapure the top spot like Jerry Rice had to do after Brian Mitchell retired.

[ultracajun]

Compared to Brian Mitchell he burned out like a bottle rocket.

He never led the entire all-purpose history of the NFL like Brian Mitchell did.

No Hall of Famer kept playing longer than normal (due to Hester) to recapure the top spot like Jerry Rice had to do after Brian Mitchell retired.

The Ferrari always turns more heads than the F150

[JamesTheJeweler]

Mitchell will NEVER get in with all this negative talk on RP.

[facelessjonmoon]

Mitchell will NEVER get in with all this negative talk on RP.

Thank you sir. Someone has to keep this board in line

[Turbine]

The Ferrari always turns more heads than the F150

A lot of truth in that statement.

[R1Letterman]

Devin Hester was a 3 time All-Pro and on two all-decade teams.

Mitchell was a 1 time All Pro.

I know we like to look at things with Vermilion & White glasses, but Hester was always going to be in as a return specialist before Mitchell due to him separating himself from the rest of his peers as a return man during his best seasons. Three times led the NFL in punt return TDs.

if he had more TDs but less yards, maybe some of those were shorter field position fields?
maybe his team had better blockers?

a. there are multiple selecting organizations so BM actually had more than 1
b. if the consensus position is he deserves to be in, but those selecting are wrong for not putting him in, how can a different subjective selection being wrong be used as evidence to justify the other wrong vote?

[RaisingCajun08]

Mitchell will NEVER get in with all this negative talk on RP.

100% Roger is a member and reads all threads here. I saw lady Goodell comment on Facebook Ragin Cajuns Football Fans page.

[R1Letterman]

Mitchell will NEVER get in with all this negative talk on RP.

Well i did once here him say on his d.c. radio show that "LSU is good". and he never really spoke much about cajuns there either

[Swamp]

Compared to Brian Mitchell he burned out like a bottle rocket.

He never led the entire all-purpose history of the NFL like Brian Mitchell did.

No Hall of Famer kept playing longer than normal (due to Hester) to recapure the top spot like Jerry Rice had to do after Brian Mitchell retired.

I hear ya, but Brady stayed longer to achieve higher numbers than Drew.

[Swamp]

[Turbine]

Now we talkin. .CFHoF