Napier will fail miserably at JMU.
He has always been a terrible OC, bailed out by his staff and the talent they found.
Who cares, we weren’t going to fire Des and hire Napier.
The man is a great coach who just landed in the best situation in the SBC.
The reality for most G5 schools since the financial flood gates are open for the bigger P4 schools is that 1 in 4 years of success is a great feat and most likely the pattern. It is far harder to build continued success on a yearly basis since the landscape has changed and our best players get plucked yearly. We will have play younger guys each year rather than develop kids for 4 years and retain like Napier was able to do. Now we develop 2 and our best are poached. Hate to say it but that is the biggest difference of when Napier was here. Des gets the same level of talent, he just cant keep them as long and build an elite veteran team.
If you can't keep them you can still reap them.
Here is the question that has to be asked and the decision that has to be made: Will a totally green first year freshmen outperform a seasoned, coached up fourth year D3 or FCS player?
If you are going to lose them after a year or two either way, you might as well go after the one that has the most immediate impact even if they are peaking.
There are currently 11 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 11 guests)