The number 1 question you can ask any of the prilvaged five

[cajungrad2001]

With athletics budget between 80 to 120 way more than Louisiana with all those resources why does P5 schools continue to pillage the G5 schools for players. With having that much of an advantage budget wise you have to steal the smaller schools best players every year.

[CajunVic]

. . . all things in life, the cream rises to the top . . . they want the cream no matter where it is made and the cream wants to be on top . . . and $$$$ . . .

[Turbine]

P5 schools are talent graveyards.

A developed 2-star will outperform the atrophied 5-star.

So to fix the flaw, they poach the devloped 2-star.

[CajunVic]

. . . don’t know about all that . . .

[RaginScotsman]

See farm systems in pro baseball.

Seems easy. Who did great at a school or a conference with less $? Slide into the DM.

[Turbine]

If P5 schools weren't talent graveyards, there would be zero need to come after former 2-star athletes.

[RaginScotsman]

If P5 schools weren't talent graveyards, there would be zero need to come after former 2-star athletes.

Correct.

Also I’m pretty sure the P5 and G5 don’t exist. TV networks coined that.

[Winning]

P5 schools are talent graveyards.

A developed 2-star will outperform the atrophied 5-star.

So to fix the flaw, they poach the devloped 2-star.

[CajunEXPRESS]

Correct.

Also I’m pretty sure the P5 and G5 don’t exist. TV networks coined that.

They exist. They actually refered to themselves as the autonomous 5. They told the NCAA exactly what and what it could do about themselves. Ever since then their only fear was being coined as an illegal cartel. That’s why the G5 have one doorway into the coming playoffs.

[cajungrad2001]

What I’m saying is simply with all that money and state politics kissing you’re behind. With all those advantages shows that schools like UL and Tulane with limited budgets still able to make top 20 .

And what I would love to see put into the bylaws of NCAA every time they buy a player with a NIL deal that should be one less scholarship that should be taken away from the school that took that player away.

[CajunEXPRESS]

What I’m saying is simply with all that money and state politics kissing you’re behind. With all those advantages shows that schools like UL and Tulane with limited budgets still able to make top 20 .

And what I would love to see put into the bylaws of NCAA every time they buy a player with a NIL deal that should be one less scholarship that should be taken away from the school that took that player away.

That’s never going to happen

[Turbine]

 

The P5 numbers include the supplemented roster transfers that go on to get drafted. This existed before the portal.

Only 61% of 5-star players survive to the NFL. Of those who do get drafted, they usually get drafted high.

Nearly 40% of 5-star athletes get buried in the talent graveyards.

[Jeaux]

I find it ironic and hypocritical to hear the UMN head coach complaining about NIL and the portal. Yes he may lose a great talent but look at his roster and see how many transfers he's poached from smaller schools. We jump on Sunbelt Billy for taking two talented guys from us but Maction PJ is still raiding Western Michigan in his 7th year. Dude is supposed to be a great recruiter and motivator. Really he has no legs to stand on here

[Ragin9221]

Let them steal our players, the player that went to Alabama that is riding that bench I take that dude !!

It works both ways

Do y’all realize how many athletes are looked over?

Oh I got offered a scholarship from Alabama, and ride the bench for 4 years!

It works both ways

If I was a coach why wouldn’t you do it ?

[Turbine]

... the player that went to Alabama that is riding that bench I take that dude !!

That is the right approach.

If a staff can coach up a 2-star, they can certainly rehabilitate a bench riding 4-star.