There are only about three maybe four mills that can make artificial athletic field turf. There are more installers than that. Making an artificial turf is not brain surgery, the only thing you can do is alter the Density or length of the blades and the makeup of the backing. The backing is usually a roll of woven geotextile material that is impregnated with a silicone material to give it more body. They use a manufacturing process to insert the "grass blades" into the backing. They also perforate the backing to let water go through.
The ground is prepared with a slight crown for football fields and a slight slope for others (to shed rain water) The perforations in the backing allow some of the rain water to penetrate the membrane. The rest drains by sheet flow to the drainage system. Under the turf is a base of either lime stabilized or cement stabilized soil, a thin layer of fine limestone for drainage. (indoor arenas are installed on a concrete floor). All of the above is variable depending on the local site conditions.
Once the turf is placed the markings are installed. They usually get a sheep shearer and "shave" the plastic blades down to the backing. They hot glue the markings in a contrasting color into the bare area. These areas have a double backing which causes the blades to be longer than the surrounding turf. This is why someone can trip by themselves while running down the field.
Once all the markings are installed and the turf is tacked down and they spread a layer of fine sand to weigh the turf down and then rubber pellets to act as a cushion. This is highly variable.
The life of an artificial turf field depends on how often it is swept and how often a magnet is pulled over the surface to pick up metal objects (you would be surprised). Weather extremes have a lot to do with it too.
So which one is better. I don't know because a lot depends on the installation methods and skill of the install crew. Also, if the field would happen to get flooded then the rubber pellets either float away or get redistributed causing uneven cushion. To redistribute the rubber is a difficult thing because the only way they can do it is with a sweeper. It's not very precise because it depends on the skill of the operator and how much static electricity is built up on the turf. (don't touch the sweeper until its been grounded. You will get a shock). The life of the turf also depends on who is keeping it up.
And as Forest Gump would say "that's all I have to say about that"