For me, the Orphan Barrel bottles were hit-and-miss. I still have a couple of them that are not open. I am pretty sure I have a bottle of the Rehtoric 23-year-old. The Forged Oak was right in price and had a great palette and nose. I think they were good, but very few were worth the price tags. Thanks for the recommendation on the Sagamore Sherry, I will have to check it out. The Midwinter Night Dram I have Act 2 and Act 7, both are delicious.