So yet another non responsive response. Put a number on it. Everyone here is _____ing about it being too low. What’s it supposed to be?
It’s a 5 day festival if I’m not mistaken. Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday. They paid $7k a day. What should it have been?
Only a non response if someone lost track of the overall thread.
You presented specifics on what the Mardi Gras Association is charging.
I said UL should run their own show as part of Hospitality Management and make a donation to the Mardi Gras Association.
So, I think fair market value rental of a Cajun Field parking lot is what the Mardi Gras Association is charging. I just think UL should be the one doing the charging.
I fully expect to see a MG float next year cancelling Ragin Pagin...
But they don’t, nor have they. The association accepts the risk, both from a liability standpoint and financial standpoint. There’s been years in the past where Mardi Gras has been terrible due to weather. I don’t know if I would want the university to accept that risk, or even put resources towards putting on a festival.
Using your logic, any function that uses university property could pretty much be done by the university, so why rent space out?
Unless one thinks "work" rhymes with "liability" that is not my logic.
The university accepts the type of liability on topic every home football game.
My logic is quit out sourcing every single function that resembles work, especially when you are giving away money.
If the positive financials dictate, I have no problem with out sourcing or renting properties.
I am saying what the MGA is charging is fair market value. (that answered your question) what the university is charging the MGA is not fair market value.
Having said that, it is very hard to constrict an allowance, once given freely.
It’s not outsourcing if you never even sourced it in the first place.
You can’t tell me what the fair charges (which would be revenue, not profit), so you can’t tell me what FMV is. Understood. To simply say “what the fair charges” ignores all expenses.
For the longest time this board has complained about the MG association screwing the university. The original thought was UL was getting paid 10-15k, which is true but ignores the 5 percent. I get curious, get the contracts, and throw out legit numbers. And all I hear is “we are getting screwed” (paraphrasing, probably). Yet nobody can tell me what they think FMV is.
~$0.13 per sq ft rental is not FMV. That I can tell you. A heady negotiator can attach a rider that guarantees a fair payout, even in the event of substandard weather in MGs case, or royalty per vehicle in CS case. You're not including in your FMV assessment the mountain of free advertising in the most visible area in Lafayette, LA. I forget the number reported by the Cronkie study, but IIRC, 160k cars a day at the corner of Bertrand & Congress. You can't buy that kind of exposure for these dealers. You can't buy that kind of ease of access, including parking, RV/Camper space and visibility for the MG festivities. Specific to the car show, not only do they make an ass load on that event, they then turnaround and give lease cars to the coaches. More advertising. They then turnaround and sell those program vehicles to the public and have the selling tool of "Hey, Billy Napier drove this truck. Hud drove this truck." The revenue is layered in the case of the Car Show. Also have to consider depreciation of property when talking about MG events. Who is paying to fix the pot holes? Who is paying for the electricity? Who is paying for the wear and tear on facilities? It goes beyond FMV and numbers on a contract.
There are currently 50 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 50 guests)