agree he aint, but im not so sure thats a bad thing…. many debate whether harper is a 5 tool or 4 tool player, ok, so your analysis drops him down to 3. Rose is barely a 2 tool player. hmmm… im not a fan of his but facts are facts… Harper was also a top prospect since his early teens, had to go to college at 16 because he was too young for draft and too good for HS, meanwhile pete rose started out in class D ball near his hometown… if his hometown doesnt have a team does he even make a team? if class D didnt exist would he have even made it at all?
“hey i played more positions than anybody therefore im awesome”- pete rose
“we checked our notes and dont see any player who constantly had to keep switching positions because they werent the best player on their own team at their position”- signed hall of fame archives
Also his uncle was a part time scout for the Reds and begged them to take him…. they had a shortage of players due to some trades and needed to fill out those extra levels of minor league rosters anyhow
Everytime all these “Huge pete rose fans” come out of the wood work i cant help but think, when did these guys watch Rose play. Back then pretty much (if you werent in his home city) your options were the NBC saturday game of the week, TBS and WGN.
So lets say the reds played cubs and braves about 20 times each and there are roughly 2 dozen saturdays during the season, so even if half of those showed the reds, thats a potential max of 50 games, barely a third.
Ahhhhh, makes more sense now. I really do appreciate the insight. See it is possible for honest questions to receive honest answer.
Im especially intrigued by the media piece now. I was under the impression the media had brought him down. (and also under the impression many on here didnt like media telling them how to view players, esp homer media, but i digress, LeauxL)
ironically the nickname was derisive…. charlie as in, i dont know this guy’s name and hustle because he ran during a walk in spring training … i guess that happens with nicknames, look how popular walk off is now, but that was initially a bad thing, because it was first said from the pitcher’s perspective, the pitcher was walking off the field (presumably with head down)… the runner scoring the walk off isnt usually walking
There are currently 19 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 19 guests)