QB Battle

[JMV JustMyView]

Disagree it affects your ranking to start the season and let’s face it we need all the help we can get to make a BCS bowl. Also Drew Brees is 5’10 and he did pretty well.

How does a players star/recruiting ranking have anything to do with the rankings to start a season or anything to do with a bcs or any other bowl game.

[Cantstandza]

Disagree it affects your ranking to start the season and let’s face it we need all the help we can get to make a BCS bowl. Also Drew Brees is 5’10 and he did pretty well.

BCS Bowl? What year is it?

[mxpxfr690]

BCS Bowl? What year is it?

Until they truly expand the playoff to include everyone it will always be the BCS playoff to me.

[Big Poppa]

Disagree it affects your ranking to start the season and let’s face it we need all the help we can get to make a BCS bowl. Also Drew Brees is 5’10 and he did pretty well.

So if you have a 3 star Qb versus a 2 star QB that will effect your preseason team rankings? Well la de freaking da. Pretty sure they look at the team as a whole.

[cajun_lannister]

So if you have a 3 star Qb versus a 2 star QB that will effect your preseason team rankings? We la de freaking da. Pretty sure they look at the team as a whole.

https://247sports.com/Player/Grayson-McCall-46054624/

[fanof71]

https://247sports.com/Player/Grayson-McCall-46054624/

Well, there you go.

[Turbine]

So if you have a 3 star Qb versus a 2 star QB that will effect your preseason team rankings? We la de freaking da. Pretty sure they look at the team as a whole.

One star to the next is usually a negligible difference in ability.

When you start having a star gap, the difference in ability can be. massive.

[Big Poppa]

A

One star to the next is usually a negligible difference in ability.

When you start having a star gap, the difference in ability can be. massive.

No doubt but I don’t think that one star on one player will make a big difference in a pre season coaches poll for an entire teams ranking as the previous poster suggested. They are going to look at o line, skilled guys around that QB and the defense when ranking a team.

[Big Poppa]

https://247sports.com/Player/Grayson-McCall-46054624/

Yep. Isn’t he considered the best in the league? Well we got a 3 star out of high school projected as starter. 3 should be better than 2.

We’ve all seen McCall play, the previous poster was saying star rating on the QB would make a difference in a teams ranking before that person has ever started one game.

https://247sports.com/player/chandler-fields-91536/

[JamesTheJeweler]

And if I'm not mistaken, Legendre was a 4 star out of high school. He's now backing up 3 stars.

[mxpxfr690]

How does a players star/recruiting ranking have anything to do with the rankings to start a season or anything to do with a bcs or any other bowl game.

The preseason poll voters look at current roster and how your recruiting rankings stack up when they vote… so yes it does affect your preseason ranking where you start… hence why the blue bloods always seem to start in the top 25 because of how good their recruiting classes have been… it is a major factor… UL needs every advantage they can get and starting in the top 25 helps.

[JMV JustMyView]

The preseason poll voters look at current roster and how your recruiting rankings stack up when they vote… so yes it does affect your preseason ranking where you start… hence why the blue bloods always seem to start in the top 25 because of how good their recruiting classes have been… it is a major factor… UL needs every advantage they can get and starting in the top 25 helps.

I want the Cajuna to finish in the top 25. Not worried about where they start. Just win and everything else will take care it's self.

[mxpxfr690]

I want the Cajuna to finish in the top 25. Not worried about where they start. Just win and everything else will take care it's self.

Agreed, but you think Cincinnati would have made the playoff last year if they started outside the top 25…. I’ll answer it for you… NO…. Start in a great position and finish in a better one.

[JMV JustMyView]

Agreed, but you think Cincinnati would have made the playoff last year if they started outside the top 25…. I’ll answer it for you… NO…. Start in a great position and finish in a better one.

Kind of like Ole Miss baseball???

[mxpxfr690]

Kind of like Ole Miss baseball???

College baseball and college football are two totally different sports when talking about post season play…. Ole miss baseball winning the natty is not even close to a G 5 getting into a 4 team playoff run by the P5…. Try again