It seems to me that we should post public questions to get answers.
These are questions that won't start to be answered until kickoff next year.
It's like coaching: You want a winning team, you want winning players? Praise in public, criticize in private.
It's true for us fans, too. Do we want a winning team, do we want to recruit winning players? Do we understand the essential importance of morale & teamwork? Then we need to keep theoretical doubts private.
Because publicly raising questions without answers, but which have negative implications, isn't just just pointless.
It is damaging.