Mitchell - our offense would rush for a billion yards with him at the helm and the backs we have
Jake - Threw way more picks as a Cajun then people seem to remember, but he was the best pure QB we have ever had. As evidenced by the fact he was one more possession from winning a Superbowl ring at QB.
Dez - I guess I lose credibility with the poster above, but like #1, we would rush for an ungodly amount of yards with him at QB and the backs/line we have. I also think his passing stats would be better now. Dez was just one of my favorite players to watch ever, a warrior.
Levi - discussed ad naseum. Dude just wins, and makes very few big mistakes. I get some of the criticism, I just don't get the depth of dislike some have for him.
Babb - I could see him as high as third. Also a very very nice guy and great engineer.
Gautier - I just like that dude more than Broadway
Broadway - was best his first year...not sure who's fault that was.
I never saw Henry, I assume he belongs somewhere in that mix but I just never saw him play.