I have a similar experience as you and Dad. I know many former players that love the guy and some (not many) that don't care for him. I wouldn't say they "can't stand him." But who don't have the same appreciation for him that many of the other former players have. And some of the ones that don't care for Robe were starters so the whole "he didn't play me" thing does not apply, and they are adults now. But you can't please everyone when you are a leader.