I didn't consider him good. Plenty of games with time to throw he threw jump balls or ones that receivers had to make great catches on to complete. Those were a lot more prevalent than hitting a receiver in stride to allow them to make a play after the catch.
The other thought is you'll have a difficult time recruiting a great throwing quarterback when you run an offense like ours. You have to allow the quarterback and skill position player to showcase their ability to get them to come on campus, and we don't do that here.