I completely understand people's view of Jay in regards to how he sometimes treats callers..I get it believe me. However, I remember when goofball Schultz came here and he mocked our name on the radio and he has that same know it all attitude that Jay has but just has a different method of displaying it. I hated that he knew nothing of our local teams and talked more Patriots than Saints.
I also attended a "fundraiser" wine tasting right before the Boise game where he was the guest speaker and got up and gave a preview of the matchup of the two teams. It was obvious to me that he knows just the basic information of the team that he gets through media reports and interviews with little other insight.
I know many people here have started to like him over Jay because he's been willing to go out and hammer Farmer on the radio (much of that deserved) to get some answers and there is certainly a place for that as people wanted answers to the Tigue debacle and you weren't getting them through any other outlet so I do applaud him for that but he doesn't impress me any more than anyone else in the market.
On Jay, yes 1420 covers all things Cajuns. I appreciate this but I completely get why they are not uber critical of the university in public due to this relationship. I don't know why this upsets as many people as it does though. You have a mutual partnership with someone who is paying you to cover sports and broadcast events, do people think that the partner is going to like it if the other is bending them over in public? That relationship won't exist very long.
Gary and Shannon are just bad and it sucks to say that because Gary is really a great guy but the show lacks depth and insight into anything.
I am still amazed to see very little bad about Ryckman's show. That is just the absolute worst for radio. Some of his guests are OK but he just has no place on radio. He can't pronounce names and in general just seems to have trouble with the English language. It pains me to listen.
I have absolutely no issue with this. My issue is that IF you are a publicist for the program, as we can all agree Mr. Moon is, do NOT claim to be a journalist when covering the program for which you are an advertising agent. Jay could be a good journalist; he writes well and speaks well, and he knows what questions to ask. But when covering the Cajuns, he is a publicist.
If you recall, he kept hammering people on here for not giving up sources, yet when asked for HIS sources, he claimed journalistic integrity demanded he not give them. People here called him on his BS, based on the fact that he is NOT a journalist when dealing with the Cajuns.
It probably comes down to personal preference. When I was younger, I wanted a homer calling games and doing local talk. Now that I'm older and more involved, I want facts and objectivity. Shultz gives you that. And it's desperately needed in our market.
I get that he probably upset people with the way he started here; I was one of those people. But to suggest that the guy knows "the basics" is ridiculous. I speak to Dave fairly often. The man is dedicated to his job and delivering a good product. And I appreciate his professionalism. I appreciate that he (and really most of 103.7 hosts) tells me what I need to hear, not what he thinks I want to hear.
I appreciate your comments. I want unbiased coverage. I want someone to be the "voice" of the fans. There is not greater connected media member to the university than Jay Walker. I also understand that he can't "throw the university under the bus" because of the relationship he and the radio station has to the university. Now, he also calls himself of a fan of the university and the sports programs. That creates a bias. He can't be objective. I get frustrated because I want him to be unbiased member of the media and he can't objectively do that. I also think it was wrong for him to position himself as a "media member" on this very board. Then, he gets mad when posters give their opinion, packs up and leaves, then slams the same fans that he entertained on this board.
Jay should never come back on this board. If he ever wants to be considered "credible", then he has to take a chance and question the administration the way he should.
Scott's strength is his NOLA sports connections. Too bad his ONLY connection is with the Pelicans.
I love that Jay is a fan. The alternative would be terrible. I love that Jay is honestly invested in the program.
Where Jay and I have disagreed is the platform on talk radio, specifically about the administration. In my opinion, you can't on one hand take a soft stance on being skeptical toward the admin, and on the other take a hard line stance on fans. I get it; fans can be annoying, over inflated, take things too seriously, read into things, etc. But still, they are the life blood of a strong athletic program, which ultimately is what Jay wants. It's what we all want (well except for a few).
Relationships complicate things, there is no doubt about that. I can't honestly say I would be an objective person when critiquing Tony Robichaux. But I do think Jay could do some good (and has asked some important questions to Farmer recently) by questioning some things that are going on within our athletic offices publicly.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)