It's however you want to slice it. Bottom line, Marlin does not attract the top recruits. Have you seen how successful we are in recruiting players in this state? We are not even attracting mid level talent in Louisiana. You say Shawn and Elfrid? Well, when we had them, how successful were we? How many times did we win our conference? If he's done so well in recruiting, why didn't we see more success with those players on the team? Because we didn't surround them with guys who could reach those levels. We went to the Big Dance and that's a feather in his cap but that also happens to lots of teams that get hot at the right time. I prefer to think that the players have as much to do with that as the coach.
You want to play devil's advocate that's fine but the main point here is that is the program any better off now than when Marlin got here? You want me to give Marlin credit for Long and Payton? Fine. I don't necessarily agree with it but I'll concede that he did well with both of them but what about the rest of the talent that our program has seen walk through the doors? If they are so talented, where is even a marginal level of success?