Outside perspective: whoever designed that Gator did an excellent job! It should be the new mascot for the Ice Gators though....
Y'all don't want a gator for a "spirit leader". Eventhough y'all named Cajun Field "The Swamp" long before U of Florida did, national perception would be that UL is copying them with field name & mascot. Also, Florida's big booster in is called the "Bull Gators."
Y'all need something unique like the culture in Acadiana. Since no one wants to bring back a true Ragin Cajun "swamp man".....I say a Crawfish named Claude would suffice.