Salamanders, given a choice between tubes containing two fruitflies or three, lunge at the tube of three1. This hints that the ability to differentiate between small numbers of objects may have evolved much earlier than scientists had thought.
Primates can spot the greater of two quantities smaller than four, without any training. Babies choose the bowl with more cookies; monkeys go for the bucket with more slices of apple.
The surprise, says Claudia Uller, of the University of Louisiana who carried out the study, was that the amphibians "failed in the same way that babies and monkeys do" - more than three objects confuses them.