Grant Fleming or Jacob Cutrera

[Clutch0364]

Its damn near impossible to compare these 2 players because both are completely different and even though they are both LB's, they both play different LB positions. One will be asked to do somepletely different things than the other so comparing the 2 is not fair. Like someone else said we should be happy with Grant because he is ours...we dont need to compare him to someone else.

[Zeebart21]

Its damn near impossible to compare these 2 players because both are completely different and even though they are both LB's, they both play different LB positions. One will be asked to do somepletely different things than the other so comparing the 2 is not fair. Like someone else said we should be happy with Grant because he is ours...we dont need to compare him to someone else.

Fine post sir.

My hope is both young men have an injury free career, and definitely live up to their potential!

Z

[ChanceEncounter]

_ Its damn near impossible to compare these 2 players because both are completely different and even though they are both LB's, they both play different LB positions. One will be asked to do somepletely different things than the other so comparing the 2 is not fair. Like someone else said we should be happy with Grant because he is ours...we dont need to compare him to someone else. _

The problem is in the word 'Career' not that they are same/dissimilar positions. You can ask if Ron Guidry or Brian Mitchell had the better career and it would be a fair question.

[snote]

i vote william

picture from J Crew (Hawaii)

[BStock]

Your theme in all posts is to take anyone to task who dares question anything regarding the almighty flagship. The person who started this post asked for a comparison or prediction on which of two former local high school stars would have a better career. You respond with a typical "know your place" post.

"besides trying to show that a UL-L player is as good as an LSU player.... "

Your post above seems to indicate that you think it is a given that every lsu player is better than any UL player. BTW, nice use of the city tag abbreviation and the hyphen to make sure it didn't get changed to UL. In addition to all those spring sports tickets to UL, where do you spend your fall sporting dollars?

i am not responding with a "know your place" post. i am responding with a "why create a thread in the hopes of starting an argument" post.

as far as the fall sports question, i spend my weekends in tiger stadium. am i not supposed to support my alma mater? what is a person to do? especially when they received an education from both schools?

that is why i spend 7-8 weekends a year in baton rouge and spend my spring weekends here in lafayette.

[Hammer58]

_ i am not responding with a "know your place" post. i am responding with a "why create a thread in the hopes of starting an argument" post.

as far as the fall sports question, i spend my weekends in tiger stadium. am i not supposed to support my alma mater? what is a person to do? especially when they received an education from both schools?

that is why i spend 7-8 weekends a year in baton rouge and spend my spring weekends here in lafayette. _

Well now we have full disclosure. It was pretty obvious where your first loyalties are.

As for the motives behind the creation of this thread, I don't know for certain sicne I ddin't create it (nor have I voted in it for that matter). But you seem to be the only one who wanted to jump in and start an argument. Is it because you can't stomach the thought of a UL fan thinking their player maight be just as good or better? I mean, whats an alum supposed to do?

[BStock]

Well now we have full disclosure. It was pretty obvious where your first loyalties are.

As for the motives behind the creation of this thread, I don't know for certain sicne I ddin't create it (nor have I voted in it for that matter). But you seem to be the only one who wanted to jump in and start an argument. Is it because you can't stomach the thought of a UL fan thinking their player maight be just as good or better? I mean, whats an alum supposed to do?

don't know? could be! i do feel that orlando thomas was the best free safety in the state during his time and he should be considered for one of the top 3 spots in UL athletics

[gridiron]

We compare schools all the time. If websites can assign stars to a high school players. If radio shows can say who had the better signing class. If Newspapers can rate a players draft value. What is wrong with looking at the players in the middle of the process?

[BStock]

We compare schools all the time. If websites can assign stars to a high school players. If radio shows can say who had the better signing class. If Newspapers can rate a players draft value. What is wrong with looking at the players in the middle of the process?

after looking back, you are right. i guess i was having a bad day friday.

[CajunAmos]

after looking back, you are right. i guess i was having a bad day friday.

Picked a bad day to stop sniffin glue?