If you don't like the '08 recruiting class...

[Zeebart21]

You guys have all 2 star recruits and you are loaded with them. There is alot of talent in that class. I am sure that McNeese is winning with alot less talent than that. Personally I am just not so convinced that Bustle knows what to do with the talent he has. You guys should give him no more than one year. You have talent.

Been back to Abbeville lately? I know you guys were fretting about losing some studs at the end, but ya'll seem to have ended up with a really strong class!

Z

[Cajun Express]

_ don't put too much stock in rivals, scout or things like all-state and all-american teams. i remember the day when the la. sports writers didn't think marshall faulk was good enough to make the all-state team. yeah, right. fact is, no one can see and properly evalute players and anyone who says they can probably has some property south of holly beach to sell you,too. it all pans out on the playing field. _

Clearly some people can pick out great athletes and players or else we would have some turnover in the top, middle, and bottom programs. Somebody is getting it right. Marshall Faulk was offered a scholarship at Ellis U, but not as a running back, so off to San Diego he went to become a great, great college back, and a hall of fame NFL star. But to say he was not picked all state, I would like to see that in writing that year.

[Geauxdeaux]

Clearly some people can pick out great athletes and players or else we would have some turnover in the top, middle, and bottom programs. Somebody is getting it right. Marshall Faulk was offered a scholarship at Ellis U, but not as a running back, so off to San Diego he went to become a great, great college back, and a hall of fame NFL star. But to say he was not picked all state, I would like to see that in writing that year.

you can look it up - i was on the all-state committee that got it wrong so i know. i'm certainly not proud of it, but again, it's impossible to know every athlete out there. of course, we didn't have the internet and a million talent experts out there to help us out back then. today, everyone who sets up a web site is an expert. not! i prefer to let evaluations to the people who are qualified and not a bunch of guys, who probably never played the sport, but call themselves experts. granted, today quality services get info from coaches and the top rankings are probably legit. but after you get past the top level, you're just guessing how good a kid really is.

[Big Buds]

I thought Marshall Faulk was interested in UL but we offered him a scholarship w/ the interest of him playing defense? Thus he went to greatness at SDSU.

[beaux66]

Going back to Abbeville in April Z. yeah we lost some big time studs. Hate that we lost the qb to USM and I hate the way he did it. Pretty dkless but that stuff happens. I do recall getting a certain assistant coach the same way from ya'll. It's hard to ask players to honor commitments when coaches show them no example to live by. Coaches always look out for themselves and then get upset when players look out for their best interest. All that preaching aside, I think we got a good class of big defensive recruits, so I am not completely upset. We are doing alot of positive stuff with facilities right now that might help some of these recruits sign on the dotted line in the future.

[Cajun Express]

_ I thought Marshall Faulk was interested in UL but we offered him a scholarship w/ the interest of him playing defense? Thus he went to greatness at SDSU. _

CDSU, Corn Dog State U, offered him on defense, not offense which is why he followed the old advise, go west young man, go west. What he did not understand was he only needed to go another fifty miles west.

http://www.jockbio.com/Bios/Faulk/Faulk_bio.html

[Cajun Express]

_ you can look it up - i was on the all-state committee that got it wrong so i know. i'm certainly not proud of it, but again, it's impossible to know every athlete out there. of course, we didn't have the internet and a million talent experts out there to help us out back then. today, everyone who sets up a web site is an expert. not! i prefer to let evaluations to the people who are qualified and not a bunch of guys, who probably never played the sport, but call themselves experts. granted, today quality services get info from coaches and the top rankings are probably legit. but after you get past the top level, you're just guessing how good a kid really is. _

You sir are vindicated: http://www2.xlibris.com/bookstore/bo...p?bookid=15026

"Many great football players were not selected on All-State teams. While it is likely that some of them should've been All-Staters, the fact was that they weren't considered the best players at their positions during their high school careers.

A few examples are running backs Marshall Faulk and Hank Lauricella, who were Heisman Trophy runners-up a few years later, and quarterbacks Terry Bradshaw, Bert Jones, Doug Williams, Stan Humphries, Bobby Hebert and David Woodley.

All of the quarterbacks played high school and college football in Louisiana, and later excelled in the National Football League."

[CajunT]

_ Going back to Abbeville in April Z. yeah we lost some big time studs. Hate that we lost the qb to USM and I hate the way he did it. Pretty dkless but that stuff happens. I do recall getting a certain assistant coach the same way from ya'll. It's hard to ask players to honor commitments when coaches show them no example to live by. Coaches always look out for themselves and then get upset when players look out for their best interest. All that preaching aside, I think we got a good class of big defensive recruits, so I am not completely upset. We are doing alot of positive stuff with facilities right now that might help some of these recruits sign on the dotted line in the future. _

Beaux66, I always enjoy your comments. You seem like a decent guy,but I have to laugh at some of your comments on the Tech board. You guys did offer Deke Jones, Damaris Johnson, Chris Richard and Luther Ambrose. In addition to those athletes ,after losing Jeffcoat to USM, you guys were scrambling to bring a QB in the last weekend. You even tried to trip in the Forreaux kid from Erath that signed with McNeese St. So when you say that at least you didn't loose any prospects to ULM or ULL, that is not exactly correct my friend. I've spoken to all these kids during recruiting, except Forreaux. Jones signed with SLU, Richard to UL and Ambrose to ULM. It think you guys did have a down year in Louisiana in recruiting. Of course, USM hurt both Tech and UL with coming back on commitments. What did Dooley have to say about this years class from Louisiana, I haven't seen any of his comments?

[beaux66]

The only comments I have ever made on there about any recruit was on the loss of the qb to southern pss. I hate them by the way. The most arrogant fans on earth. I have no idea who Tech offered or didn't offer so I can't comment either way. I do know that ULM got some recruits that I wouldn't mind having but I don't know one way or the other if they were ever recruited by Tech. I do know that Dooley wasn't too keen on going the JC route. I think he only actively recruited one. ULM got alot of great ones but most were JC's. As far as Ambrose goes, he sounds like someone we should have recruited if we didn't. YOu must be confusing me with someone else because I never said we didn't lose anyone to UL or ULM because I honestly have to say that I have no idea.

[Louisiana84]

Y'all get too worked up over recruiting. Until these kids prove something on the field, there's no telling how many 'stars' they're worth.