Lucroy is killin it this year and don't see him slowing down in the near future. But IMO, he blossomed too late to have HOF numbers. Looking at his numbers compared to other catchers who will receive HOF votes, Ivan Rodriguez and Joe Mauer had well over 1,000 hits by 28 years of age compared to Lucroys 580 (and more gold gloves).
Not trying to downplay his accomplishments at all or saying you're wrong, just interested in opinions regarding what they consider hall of fame worthy.