Are you one of the wise men?I agree with you that Hud and Willis must have had a decent relationship for Willis to keep this under wraps until the end of signing day. But, if "we all knew" (including Hud) that we were one and done with Willis, we'd have passed on him. Willis did not re-establish himself at UL, and we didn't improve defensively under his coordination. His pedigree got him the interview/offer at FSU. He's probably better off as a LB coach at an established program than being a DC at UL (financially and assignment-wise).
Personally, I'd like to see Hud find a guy that has a similar resume to Hud (young, energetic, trying to build a career, built his existing career within 300 miles of Lafayette, and has the ability to use mid major talent intelligently). I'm not a fan of guys that spent most of their careers in programs that have had the pick of the litter and think their actual coaching skills had something to do with the success of those programs.
It would be seriously wise, IMO, to find someone with existing ties to Louisiana recruiting. There is no reason we cannot locate, recruit, teach and retain great defensive talent in this state, or in the immediate areas adjoining this state.