Hey Turbine, I'm in the band and get what you're saying, but have to defend the band a little.
We're doing a job, same as the football team, cheerleaders, and the Ragin Jazz. If we don't play in those last minutes, people start to call us dispondent and say that we're not doing what we're supposed to do. The band director gets an earful which is passed to us even though we had nothing to do with playing/not playing and we eventually start to lose our already non-existent funding because University higher-ups are displeased with us. It's happened before and I think we'd like to prevent it from happening again.
I know that seems a little extreme for playing in the last 3 or 4 minutes in a big game, but we played the same in those last minutes as we did for the rest of the game and that's what we're there to do. When they make a 1st, we play the Fight Song. Time-out or quarter change, we play a longer song to entertain the crowd.
Like I said earlier, though, I understand what you're saying and can't really disagree with it. Thanks for the kind remarks and criticisms. I'll make sure that it's passed on to someone that can fix the problem and find the balance between playing too much and not enough in critical moments!