SB portal

While it is true that some girls transfer out of one school to attend another, it is much less common than for guys. If you recall last year the only Louisiana girls in the portal were those who had already been dismissed from the team for various reasons.

Considering the closeness of this group of girls among themselves, the coaches and the fans, and further considering our success this year and prospects for even more success in the next 2-3 years, it is very unlikely that we lose any girl who played a significant role this year.

The money doesn't flow to girls like it does to guys, and no school is going to risk an NCAA investigation for tampering to get even an All-American female athlete, especially in a non-revenue sport.

Conventional wisdom:
Keep the g5 out of playoffs in favor of mediocre p5s often with losing records in conference.

Also conventional wisdom:
Pretend we care by giving the g5 "extra" slots on various award teams and say see we don't keep them out (although it is just so we can put those players on p5 transfer portal radars)e

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RougaWhite&Blue

Conventional wisdom:
Keep the g5 out of playoffs in favor of mediocre p5s often with losing records in conference
Also conventional wisdom:
Pretend we care by giving the g5 "extra" slots on various award teams and say see we don't keep them out (although it is just so we can put those players on p5 transfer portal radars)

---

The thing about conventional wisdom is that it is rarely conventional and almost never wise.

At least this year [in softball] no G5 was excluded from the NCAA Tournament for arbitrary reasons; and the only G5 that possibly should have hosted was Louisiana, and we didn't get hosed on that front as badly as a P5 [Baylor].

There isn't a college softball coach in the country who didn't know who Mihyia Davis, or for that matter Lauren Allred, is well before Ms. Davis was placed on the AA team. If someone is coming for Mihyia, they didn't decide to do so because some sportswriters put her on an AA team.

One additional observation. In softball, Louisiana is not just another G5 program, we are an ELITE program which happens to be in the perennially highest rated G5 conference in the country. Even with the disadvantages of being a "G5 school", Louisiana is ranked by D1 Softball as the 19th best program in Division 1. We have been in every NCAA Tournament in this century; we have reached at least the Regional Championship game for 15 consecutive tournaments; we have nearly 1900 wins as a program; we have as many NCAA WCWS appearances as Northwestern, Texas or LSU, and more than Georgia or Baylor.

Girls who leave here for a 'better program' have a very small pool of more attractive alternatives.

"rarely conventional and almost never wise"....pretty much describes any post from RW&B...

Well, TSAB is coming after one of our freshmen with NIL money.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MelRock

Well, TSAB is coming after one of our freshmen with NIL money.

---

This goes to show that maybe the Smarts on here are really not too smart . . .

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fanof71

"rarely conventional and almost never wise"....pretty much describes any post from RW&B...

---

see also ahead of his time, just as most so called conspiracy theories usually come true six months later, see very next informative post from mel rock the one right after your bot generated auto response

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MelRock

Well, TSAB is coming after one of our freshmen with NIL money.

---

how long until they call us TSAB as well, they have stolen everything else they have. technically, this might be the first one that would actually be accurate even if they used it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MelRock

Well, TSAB is coming after one of our freshmen with NIL money.

---

If that is true [and I acknowledge that it may well be], it is tampering and is an NCAA violation. Not that the NCAA will do anything about it, but it is clearly a violation to offer money to a student athlete to transfer from a school to which they are already contractually obligated. They can certainly legally offer money, but it cannot be tied to a transfer obligation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VObserver

The thing about conventional wisdom is that it is rarely conventional and almost never wise.

At least this year [in softball] no G5 was excluded from the NCAA Tournament for arbitrary reasons; and the only G5 that possibly should have hosted was Louisiana, and we didn't get hosed on that front as badly as a P5 [Baylor].

There isn't a college softball coach in the country who didn't know who Mihyia Davis, or for that matter Lauren Allred, is well before Ms. Davis was placed on the AA team. If someone is coming for Mihyia, they didn't decide to do so because some sportswriters put her on an AA team.

One additional observation. In softball, Louisiana is not just another G5 program, we are an ELITE program which happens to be in the perennially highest rated G5 conference in the country. Even with the disadvantages of being a "G5 school", Louisiana is ranked by D1 Softball as the 19th best program in Division 1. We have been in every NCAA Tournament in this century; we have reached at least the Regional Championship game for 15 consecutive tournaments; we have nearly 1900 wins as a program; we have as many NCAA WCWS appearances as Northwestern, Texas or LSU, and more than Georgia or Baylor.

Girls who leave here for a 'better program' have a very small pool of more attractive alternatives.

---

you are preaching to the choir, however speakimg of baylor, the media/p5 angst for christian schools might be ony thing that outweighs their anti G5 efforts. see many even on here that while are g5 fans, also dont like some christian schools winning on their turf, lol